Hey guys, once we get a thesis down we will be able to start making our argument. Please post some of your ideas of what you think our argument is, then I will put it all together into a paragraph for us to build off of.
Dan
Roid Rage
Wednesday, November 21, 2012
Monday, November 19, 2012
Thomas Upham graded post #5 (article from Kyle Summers)
The Virus of Steroids in Baseball: Article from Kyle
Summers
It was to many people belief that The Steroid Era had been
declared over, or at least the league’s top players would be smart enough to
not take steroids. Roger Clemens and Barry Bonds trials had just ended so
baseball fans could finally have peace with PEDs. Think again, Possible 2012 NL
Batting Champ Melky Cabrera, and 2011 and possible 2012 NL MVP have had raised
testosterone levels during a recent PED test by the MLB. While MLB tries to
increase the range of PEDs they can test for, the number of players testing
positive has spiked this past season. Even though the MLB becomes more and more
determined to crack down on PED users, you will never be able to eradicate PEDs
from baseball. There is always a player out there you wants to take the easy
way out gain the upper hand. But Bug Selig (Commissioner of the MLB) cannot be
held accountable for positive tests, he states “We’re upset any time a player
tests positive. But it means we have a good testing program in place.” He also
compares the MLB testing policy to the Olympic testing policy saying “I really
don’t think baseball is any cleaner or dirtier than Olympic sports, and they
have the so-called gold standard of testing.”
Thomas Upham graded post #4 (Database)
2013 Hall of Shame
This article speaks on many different topics that include
who is on the Hall of Fame ballot for 2013, History of Performance Enhancing
Drug users on the Hall of Fame ballot, and also the impact of Roger Clemens
verdict on his recent Perjury trial. The article mentions the names of key
players that are on the Ballot for the first time, which includes Roger
Clemens, Barry Bonds, and Sammy Sosa. All of these players have what it takes
to get into the Hall statistically, but as history shows, if you are suspected
of PED use, you will not get into the Hall of Fame. Whether you have admitted
to the speculation or not. The history of PED speculated users on the ballot
most notably include Mark McGuire and Rafael Palmeiro. Neither of these players
have even come close to being inducted into the Hall. Finally, the most
discussed topic in the article is how the voters will be affected by Roger Clemens’s
acquittal of perjury charges. A couple of writers say that their opinion on his
induction remains unchanged. Tim Brown of Yahoo! Sports said of the acquittal, ''It
doesn't move me an inch, whether or not the government could prove its case, it
doesn't change the facts the way I see them. I won't vote for anyone I believe
took steroids or performance-enhancers, and so I won't vote for Clemens.” Inversely
Peter Abraham of the Boston Globe says ''The verdict can only help Clemens, but
it may not be enough.” But when it comes down to it, the verdict does not have
a huge impact. The trial was to see if Clemens would go to jail, while the Hall
voters vote to determine if Clemens should be able to be considered one of the
MLBs greatest players.
Tyler Ruggerio Graded Post 5 (Academic Source
http://www.lexisnexis.com.ezproxy.uwc.edu/hottopics/lnacademic/?
This article "Selig Says Steroid Era Is Basically Over" by Michael S. Schmidt talks about the long history of the Steroid Era, and how its end is approaching. He talks about Bud Selig, the head of the Major League Baseball, and how he has done so much over his 17 years as head. Whether it be settled with the Player's Union, increased team's income, and made the game expand outside the United States. Selig acknowledges the long history of steroids in baseball. In the beginning Selig was did not go full on immediately after finding out about the drugs. However, though he started with the Major League testing back in 03. Shortly after Selig was working with Congress to persuade the Players Union to make testing tougher. Selig in a statement said, ''The use of steroids and amphetamines amongst today's players has greatly subsided and is virtually nonexistent, as our testing results have shown.", he has proven saying that during a test they took in 2009 that only two players out of 3,722 samples tested positive. Significant decrease sense the peak of the Steroid Era. Bob Costas, a commentator, agreed with Selig saying that the worst of the steroids is behind us. However, there will be a few who decide that they want to chance it and still take steroids to enhance their performance.
This article "Selig Says Steroid Era Is Basically Over" by Michael S. Schmidt talks about the long history of the Steroid Era, and how its end is approaching. He talks about Bud Selig, the head of the Major League Baseball, and how he has done so much over his 17 years as head. Whether it be settled with the Player's Union, increased team's income, and made the game expand outside the United States. Selig acknowledges the long history of steroids in baseball. In the beginning Selig was did not go full on immediately after finding out about the drugs. However, though he started with the Major League testing back in 03. Shortly after Selig was working with Congress to persuade the Players Union to make testing tougher. Selig in a statement said, ''The use of steroids and amphetamines amongst today's players has greatly subsided and is virtually nonexistent, as our testing results have shown.", he has proven saying that during a test they took in 2009 that only two players out of 3,722 samples tested positive. Significant decrease sense the peak of the Steroid Era. Bob Costas, a commentator, agreed with Selig saying that the worst of the steroids is behind us. However, there will be a few who decide that they want to chance it and still take steroids to enhance their performance.
Thomas Upham graded post #3 (From Kara's article)
Braun and the Faulty Test: Response to Kara’s
Article
Ryan Braun recently had a positive Performance Enhancing Drugs,
which currently being repealed due to the fact that his positive test had not
been delivered according to MLB’s testing policy. Despite the fact that Braun
had tested positive, it is almost meaningless and has to be discounted because it
was not delivered in 44 hours. This article speaks on how this is a major hit
to the six billion dollar industry because it was not able to catch a man who
should be punished. It also has a major impact on the credibility of test in
history. Even more importantly, this article speaks on the major problem of
confidentiality and past PED test in the history of baseball. It brings up the
positive test that had revealed Alex Rodriguez as a PED user. Because of these “hidden”
tests MLB has a lot of questions to answer. How many other tests had been
hidden from the public? Why were these hidden if MLB wanted to crack down on
PED users? And how many players does the public see as clean, when in reality
they are PED users? If baseball does not fix this problem, it can start a
demise that could be detrimental.
http://aol.sportingnews.com/mlb/story/2012-02-25/ryan-braun-drug-test-results-alex-rodriguez-steroids
Tyler Ruggerio Graded Post 4 (Academic Source)
http://www.lexisnexis.com.ezproxy.uwc.edu/hottopics/lnacademic/?
From the New York Times, this article "Hall of Famers and Steroids Don't Mix", by Rachel Brooklyn argues a previous article ''Let Steroids Into the Hall of Fame,'' by Zev Chafets about whether or not to allow players who have tested positive into the Baseball Hall of Fame. Brooklyn talks about the fact that a inglorious deed such as doping should not be dignified with allowing guilty players to have their name in the Hall of Fame. This author argues that allowing players who have taken drugs into the Hall of Fame taints all the records and accomplishments. The clean records from clean great baseball players are the mark they left, and the allow those records to be time and time again beat will soon make those records not as impressive as they once were. Brooklyn also says that the use of steroids is just wrong. No player should have an easy pill to make them better. If they want to get better, they can practice and lift more. No "Hulk-like strength" as Brooklyn puts it. She criticizes his statement that baseball players should be allowed to choose whether or not they want to take steroids. However, she says, Chafets fails to mention anything about the legal aspect of the drug; considering taking steroids is illegal. Brooklyn states that if all people had Chafets attitude about baseball and mixing it with steroids that that entire game would be a corrupt law breaking professional organization. She criticizes the fact that Chafets seems to think that because the players in baseball are professionals that somehow it puts them above the law. Brooklyn goes even wider then just the confinements of baseball. She talks about the effect it will have on kids who look up to baseball players as role models. If a kid's role model is doing steroids then the kid will think that it's okay to take steroids as well to enhance their performance in sports. She ends with saying that all levels of baseball will be infected with steroids, and that besides being unfair steroids are a dangerous risk.
From the New York Times, this article "Hall of Famers and Steroids Don't Mix", by Rachel Brooklyn argues a previous article ''Let Steroids Into the Hall of Fame,'' by Zev Chafets about whether or not to allow players who have tested positive into the Baseball Hall of Fame. Brooklyn talks about the fact that a inglorious deed such as doping should not be dignified with allowing guilty players to have their name in the Hall of Fame. This author argues that allowing players who have taken drugs into the Hall of Fame taints all the records and accomplishments. The clean records from clean great baseball players are the mark they left, and the allow those records to be time and time again beat will soon make those records not as impressive as they once were. Brooklyn also says that the use of steroids is just wrong. No player should have an easy pill to make them better. If they want to get better, they can practice and lift more. No "Hulk-like strength" as Brooklyn puts it. She criticizes his statement that baseball players should be allowed to choose whether or not they want to take steroids. However, she says, Chafets fails to mention anything about the legal aspect of the drug; considering taking steroids is illegal. Brooklyn states that if all people had Chafets attitude about baseball and mixing it with steroids that that entire game would be a corrupt law breaking professional organization. She criticizes the fact that Chafets seems to think that because the players in baseball are professionals that somehow it puts them above the law. Brooklyn goes even wider then just the confinements of baseball. She talks about the effect it will have on kids who look up to baseball players as role models. If a kid's role model is doing steroids then the kid will think that it's okay to take steroids as well to enhance their performance in sports. She ends with saying that all levels of baseball will be infected with steroids, and that besides being unfair steroids are a dangerous risk.
Thomas Upham graded post #2 (Database)
MVP award and PEDs
Bill Madden’s “Writers won't strip Ryan of his NL MVP”
article posted in the NEW YORK DAILY NEWS speaks on how the MLB MVP
award is retained despite the fact that there are known PED users during the
reign of that specific season. The current issue is the fact that the Milwaukee
Brewers outfielder is under suspicion of taking PEDs, but the writers declared
he will be able to keep his MVP award. It was said that the BBWAA (Baseball
Writers Association of America) discussed revoking MVP awards, but eventually
decided to let the players keep them due to the complexity of revoking and
redistributing these awards, and under what kinds of determinants. The article
also brings up times in history when the MVP award was kept, despite a PED
admission. Specifically, it goes into depth about Jose Canseco’s admission and
his 1988 AL MVP award. Mike Greenwell (the runner up of the MVP that season), who
disagrees with the stance the BBWAA has taken on this issue. Greenwell says "Where's
my MVP? Canseco's an admitted steroid user.
I was clean. If they're going to start putting asterisks by things, let's put
one by the MVP." And later says "I do have a problem with losing the
MVP to an admitted steroids user". The article also touches on other MVPs who
have not had to give up their awards despite PED admissions/speculations that
include 3-time MVP Alex Rodriguez, 7-time MVP Barry Bonds, Ken Caminiti, Sammy
Sosa (speculated) and Jason Giambi. And
to conclude the article, Bill Madden touches on the BBWAAs different approach
to PED users getting into the Hall Of Fame. The view is that Steroid users can
win all of the awards they want on steroids, they will just be excluded from
the Hall of Fame.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)