Monday, November 19, 2012

Tyler Ruggerio Graded Post 4 (Academic Source)

http://www.lexisnexis.com.ezproxy.uwc.edu/hottopics/lnacademic/?

From the New York Times, this article "Hall of Famers and Steroids Don't Mix", by Rachel Brooklyn argues a previous article ''Let Steroids Into the Hall of Fame,'' by Zev Chafets about whether or not to allow players who have tested positive into the Baseball Hall of Fame. Brooklyn talks about the fact that a inglorious deed such as doping should not be dignified with allowing guilty players to have their name in the Hall of Fame. This author argues that allowing players who have taken drugs into the Hall of Fame taints all the records and accomplishments. The clean records from clean great baseball players are the mark they left, and the allow those records to be time and time again beat will soon make those records not as impressive as they once were. Brooklyn also says that the use of steroids is just wrong. No player should have an easy pill to make them better. If they want to get better, they can practice and lift more. No "Hulk-like strength" as Brooklyn puts it. She criticizes his statement that baseball players should be allowed to choose whether or not they want to take steroids. However, she says, Chafets fails to mention anything about the legal aspect of the drug; considering taking steroids is illegal. Brooklyn states that if all people had Chafets attitude about baseball and mixing it with steroids that that entire game would be a corrupt law breaking professional organization. She criticizes the fact that Chafets seems to think that because the players in baseball are professionals that somehow it puts them above the law. Brooklyn goes even wider then just the confinements of baseball. She talks about the effect it will have on kids who look up to baseball players as role models. If a kid's role model is doing steroids then the kid will think that it's okay to take steroids as well to enhance their performance in sports. She ends with saying that all levels of baseball will be infected with steroids, and that besides being unfair steroids are a dangerous risk.     

No comments:

Post a Comment