Monday, November 19, 2012

Kara Wait graded post #4

MLB Testing program fair or foul?- USA Today Newspaper Article outlines different fundamentals with Baseballs Steroid testing program.

http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/educate/ondcp/lessons/Activity16.pdf

First of all, I love this article.  Although it is from 2003, it has many elements of what I was looking for.  This article outlines the element of health and the long-term effects of steroid use.

Marvin Miller, former head of the Major League Baseball Players Association was interviewed for this article.  He states that steroid testing goes to far and that it is an invasion of privacy.  He states, "Everybody knows....that its harmful, well, I'd like to see the evidence and I don't mean just anecdotal evidence.  I mean evidence based on tests".  He stays that testing goes too far an that he thinks that it is not appropriate for an employer or union to invade the privacy of people without there being probable cause.

Miller also states that there is short term studies done outline how oral steroids within a week cause good cholesterol to plummet.  Also that steroids also have been associated with liver abnormalities and psychological dependence and in some people significant increases in aggression.  All of which he says that he wouldn't spend a penny, not a nickel of tax dollars on such a study because its "obvious' they can benefit a baseball player and their performance.

Building off Miller's interview, another element that is outlined is the need to perform the testing.  In the article it states that the American Civil Liberties Union says on its Web site: "Driven by an industry-led panic that drug use is common.  Employers today requires tens of millions of American workers to pass a urine test to get a new job or to keep the one they have.  Most employers, however, have never been examined their programs to see if the investment is paying dividends through decreased accidents and absenteeism".  All of which help support that drug testing is easier to comply with then to face all the hassles of not doing it and having people on your back. 

Finally, the statement found at the end of the article is perfect.  Owners  value home runs and fans love balls going over a fence.  The large majority of fans don't care about steroid use.

No comments:

Post a Comment